Royal Mail develops tool to count the carbon costs of mail

A Life Cycle Assessment tool to measure the footprint of commercial mail has been welcomed even if the first iteration falls short of the promise.

MarketReach, the marketing arm of Royal Mail, has developed a Life Cycle Assessment tool to demonstrate the relatively low impact that postal promotion can have compared to other media. Its introduction has been welcomed by the Strategic Mailing partnership, the body that exists to promote the interests of direct mail agencies printers and mailing houses.

However, MarketReach in explaining how to make mail more sustainable draws on some of the dubious assertions contained in the Using Mail More Sustainably best practice guide first published last year. Thus advice to avoid using blue colours because the inks take more energy to dry, use lower pigment load inks for the same energy saving reason, specify the use of biodegradable inks and reducing ink coverage still stands. 

MarketReach worked with US used sustainability consultancy WSP in creating its life cycles analysis calculator which will be available to all users, though is hard to find as yet. It serves up several examples: of postcards, ‘average’ magazines, ‘average’ catalogues and so on that might be delivered through the post. There is no explanation as to how these figures are arrived at, so carry little incentive for those along the production chain to deliver better figures than those posted. An invitation to “Please find the data summations here” leads to a generic US website for comparing the carbon footprint of some everyday products, but not printed items and with no validation.

Some of the figures published seem a little odd too. An A4 leaflet has a carbon footprint of 28.44g from materials, but an average magazine comes in at 133.6g for materials. If a similar paper has been used, this is a very low pagination magazine. An A4 catalogue weighs in a 190.79g for materials (50% more than the magazine) with 128.44g for ink.

Nevertheless it is a step towards countering the ‘digital communication is good, physical communication bad’ arguments that have gripped brands and marketers in recent years. Other studies have shown that printed communication is highly effective, notably work by JicMail, but these have not considered the environmental impacts.

Much of the advice in the report is sound: redesign for recycling and reuse for example, avoid waste through managing mailing lists, avoid excess trim in designs. The authors do get a little excited about biodegradable inks which are only commercially available for some flexible packaging applications, and the specification of algae as a component of printing ink, which is currently under investigation and some time away from any commercial availability. It also advises mail users to “ask your to assess the likely carbon impact of your next mailer and for any recommendations to reduce this further”, which could encourage laggard printers to sharpen up their act.

Chair of the SMP Lucy Swanston says the information will help those who use or are thinking about using commercial mail to justify their choice, adding: “The SMP hopes this move by MarketReach marks a milestone for the industry, highlighting the importance of creating sustainable business practices that align with environmental goals. The life cycle assessment and best practice guide will contribute to the sustainable future of the industry by providing SMP members with a resource that will help discussions with brands when creating mail campaigns.”