Gareth Ward contemplates where print is strong and where it is hiding its light under a bushel.
The hunt for new applications for printing and printers continues apace. And with urgency. The continuing rise in price of everything that is needed to print, from energy to inks, paper to transport, is going to force the industry’s customers into reconsidering their commitment to ink on paper. For some, where print is the actual product like greetings cards and books, there may be a reversal of the trend towards ever shorter runs and ever shorter turnarounds, but at the expense of fewer designs or titles. There may be a lower cost per unit to mitigate the effects of higher material prices, and there is a greater risk of being left with unsold copies with a longer print run than with the print on demand model, but for some publishers it would seem to be a worthwhile risk.
Where print is merely advertising the product, the chances are that print will be in less demand, unless its value and effectiveness can be demonstrated, which has always been difficult compared to, say, counting page views or email opens. On the other hand more and more data is coming to light to show just how ineffective online advertising may be and that it can frequently be fraudulent. But not enough to change attitudes. In the immediate future the cost advantages of digital channels will prevail especially with an economic recession looking likely.
One area that marketing departments are giving more consideration is the impact of the pack on the shelf. Many are using the choice and style of packaging to influence a consumer’s choice to a greater extent than ever before. If a consumer recognises the brand in the shop in less than a couple of seconds, there is a greater chance they may the buy it. Equally packaging can communicate that it shares the lifestyle outlook of the consumer. An artisan produced vegetable snack came in an uncoated board with relatively few graphics, a cut out and unfortunately a plastic bag; it appeared the perfect product, produced by hand perhaps in a kitchen somewhere not too distant from the supermarket. That was the message from the packaging. The product was actually a brand belonging to Pepsico, one of the largest producers of snacks and drinks on the planet.
It shows that packaging is one of those areas where there is a greater demand for what print can do. The pack would not have been chosen had it been emblazoned with a Pepsi logo. Further, research shows that any kind of enhancement can make a package stand out from its peers, enhancing chances of ending up in the consumer’s trolley or basket. Foil, varnish, neon colours and cut aways are all good ways to lift awareness. For foods that have an artisan ethos, more stripped back choices convey the environmental message – even down to the used of kraft materials and corrugated as ‘less refined, less industrial’ packaging. Plastic is certainly out.
Printed packaging also plays a part in promoting products purchased through a portal. The box the product arrives in is increasingly part of the consumer experience and needs to make a statement in its own right, one of the reasons for the continuing growth in printing on corrugated boards that we highlight in this issue. The secondary packaging too needs to work harder once the product has been put away into a cupboard. It serves as a reminder to the consumer to buy that product again. Print has a part to play there too, eye catching and finger catching sensations combine to increase the likelihood a product will be remembered positively.
In short if the use of print in advertising is going to continue to diminish, packaging provides proof that print has a strong future. Those lessons ought to be conveyed to the advertising and marketing departments away from packaging. If a choice of print effect and materials can deliver emotional impact via packaging – and studies have shown that when more than one sense is engaged recall is considerably stronger – then it should be the same for other printed items.
Some know this, almost instinctively. Money off vouchers are enhanced with a touch of foil and are perceived to have more value. They will therefore be kept longer increasing the chance of that customer response. Book jackets have always exploited every print technique available: foil, varnishes of all kinds, neons and creative die cutting, either alone or combined with each other. Publishers though do not have the scientifically collected data to prove this. Very few have done A/B testing to discover which effects are, well, most effective. They tend to follow each other and if a title using all manner of effects becomes a best seller, it sets a trend for others to imitate.
But book jackets do matter. At the height of the Harry Potter wave, the publisher created an adult edition; that is one with a more subdued jacket that would not look out of place being read on the daily commute. That book buyer was unlikely to be seen reading a book with a cover intended to attract children, but would buy it in the right context. Full marks for trying something different.
The question to ask is whether that decision came from the printer, the designer or the marketing department at the publisher? All too often the printer does not get a word in. All too often the printer will be told a job is coming; it arrives as a print ready PDF and is delivered to the specified address in the required amount and hopefully to the specified quality standards. The printer is at the end of the line.
And while that remains the case the printer has only a limited ability to shape their future. Smarter printers know this; printers outside the commoditised mainstream know this; some in direct mail, some in packaging, know this. These companies are adept at presenting their customers with ideas and innovation. For this is missing across the spectrum of industry and marketing.
It is not easy. It is not natural. It is not something that the industry’s customers expect. Over decades printers have acquiesced in the separation between those that design and those that produce, thinking that thanks to a large printing press, the value lay in production.
They were wrong then and are wrong now. When brands can buy print at the click of a mouse, why would they remain loyal to any particular print provider? There is convenience, there is location, there is a proven quality. None of these is irreplaceable or enough of a barrier to prevent a different decision being taken next year.
The printer, however, that presents innovation and ideas is in a stronger position. They are doing things that the fellow down the road is not. Those innovations might be about the choice of substrate, they might be about the use of foil or varnish to attract the eye and touch; they might be about colours beyond four-colour process; they might be about formats. Ideally they will add up to something that the contact has not seen before. Because it seems that today’s buyers have seen very little about what print can do. Educating customers is one of the biggest challenges that printers face today.
To do this successfully, printers will need to understand the marketers language and will need to be able to quote the research, to point to the case studies and understand the objectives of brand positioning, return on marketing investment and the various measures that the success or otherwise of a campaign is judged on.
The printer will need to do their own research, calling on the expertise of supplier-partners, the resources of the industry’s media (both in print and whatever sector the client is in) and they need to understand the industry’s past by checking out the library at St Bride’s say.
If the economy is going to go into recession as seems increasingly likely, then printers need to be prepared. Now is the time to consider what it is they are selling. And the most powerful tool they can be selling today is about innovation and ideas. This is what is in short supply because innovation comes from making new connections between experiences, technologies and knowledge. Designers today have little experience, do not understand print technologies and lack the knowledge.
Printers on the other hand have this in abundance. This is the all too frequently untapped resource that will stimulate the new products and applications that the industry depends on for its future. It is no coincidence that many large packaging companies have customer experience centres to stimulate the connections that lead to new products. There are too few commercial printers with any similar set up. That needs to change and quickly. The printers that cannot do this, that are only at the receiving end of the PDF, will become less and less relevant to their customers. Because ultimately print is only a minor part of what those customers are buying.
The path to invigorating print lies with innovation
Gareth Ward contemplates where print is strong and where it is hiding its light under a bushel.
The hunt for new applications for printing and printers continues apace. And with urgency. The continuing rise in price of everything that is needed to print, from energy to inks, paper to transport, is going to force the industry’s customers into reconsidering their commitment to ink on paper. For some, where print is the actual product like greetings cards and books, there may be a reversal of the trend towards ever shorter runs and ever shorter turnarounds, but at the expense of fewer designs or titles. There may be a lower cost per unit to mitigate the effects of higher material prices, and there is a greater risk of being left with unsold copies with a longer print run than with the print on demand model, but for some publishers it would seem to be a worthwhile risk.
Where print is merely advertising the product, the chances are that print will be in less demand, unless its value and effectiveness can be demonstrated, which has always been difficult compared to, say, counting page views or email opens. On the other hand more and more data is coming to light to show just how ineffective online advertising may be and that it can frequently be fraudulent. But not enough to change attitudes. In the immediate future the cost advantages of digital channels will prevail especially with an economic recession looking likely.
One area that marketing departments are giving more consideration is the impact of the pack on the shelf. Many are using the choice and style of packaging to influence a consumer’s choice to a greater extent than ever before. If a consumer recognises the brand in the shop in less than a couple of seconds, there is a greater chance they may the buy it. Equally packaging can communicate that it shares the lifestyle outlook of the consumer. An artisan produced vegetable snack came in an uncoated board with relatively few graphics, a cut out and unfortunately a plastic bag; it appeared the perfect product, produced by hand perhaps in a kitchen somewhere not too distant from the supermarket. That was the message from the packaging. The product was actually a brand belonging to Pepsico, one of the largest producers of snacks and drinks on the planet.
It shows that packaging is one of those areas where there is a greater demand for what print can do. The pack would not have been chosen had it been emblazoned with a Pepsi logo. Further, research shows that any kind of enhancement can make a package stand out from its peers, enhancing chances of ending up in the consumer’s trolley or basket. Foil, varnish, neon colours and cut aways are all good ways to lift awareness. For foods that have an artisan ethos, more stripped back choices convey the environmental message – even down to the used of kraft materials and corrugated as ‘less refined, less industrial’ packaging. Plastic is certainly out.
Printed packaging also plays a part in promoting products purchased through a portal. The box the product arrives in is increasingly part of the consumer experience and needs to make a statement in its own right, one of the reasons for the continuing growth in printing on corrugated boards that we highlight in this issue. The secondary packaging too needs to work harder once the product has been put away into a cupboard. It serves as a reminder to the consumer to buy that product again. Print has a part to play there too, eye catching and finger catching sensations combine to increase the likelihood a product will be remembered positively.
In short if the use of print in advertising is going to continue to diminish, packaging provides proof that print has a strong future. Those lessons ought to be conveyed to the advertising and marketing departments away from packaging. If a choice of print effect and materials can deliver emotional impact via packaging – and studies have shown that when more than one sense is engaged recall is considerably stronger – then it should be the same for other printed items.
Some know this, almost instinctively. Money off vouchers are enhanced with a touch of foil and are perceived to have more value. They will therefore be kept longer increasing the chance of that customer response. Book jackets have always exploited every print technique available: foil, varnishes of all kinds, neons and creative die cutting, either alone or combined with each other. Publishers though do not have the scientifically collected data to prove this. Very few have done A/B testing to discover which effects are, well, most effective. They tend to follow each other and if a title using all manner of effects becomes a best seller, it sets a trend for others to imitate.
But book jackets do matter. At the height of the Harry Potter wave, the publisher created an adult edition; that is one with a more subdued jacket that would not look out of place being read on the daily commute. That book buyer was unlikely to be seen reading a book with a cover intended to attract children, but would buy it in the right context. Full marks for trying something different.
The question to ask is whether that decision came from the printer, the designer or the marketing department at the publisher? All too often the printer does not get a word in. All too often the printer will be told a job is coming; it arrives as a print ready PDF and is delivered to the specified address in the required amount and hopefully to the specified quality standards. The printer is at the end of the line.
And while that remains the case the printer has only a limited ability to shape their future. Smarter printers know this; printers outside the commoditised mainstream know this; some in direct mail, some in packaging, know this. These companies are adept at presenting their customers with ideas and innovation. For this is missing across the spectrum of industry and marketing.
It is not easy. It is not natural. It is not something that the industry’s customers expect. Over decades printers have acquiesced in the separation between those that design and those that produce, thinking that thanks to a large printing press, the value lay in production.
They were wrong then and are wrong now. When brands can buy print at the click of a mouse, why would they remain loyal to any particular print provider? There is convenience, there is location, there is a proven quality. None of these is irreplaceable or enough of a barrier to prevent a different decision being taken next year.
The printer, however, that presents innovation and ideas is in a stronger position. They are doing things that the fellow down the road is not. Those innovations might be about the choice of substrate, they might be about the use of foil or varnish to attract the eye and touch; they might be about colours beyond four-colour process; they might be about formats. Ideally they will add up to something that the contact has not seen before. Because it seems that today’s buyers have seen very little about what print can do. Educating customers is one of the biggest challenges that printers face today.
To do this successfully, printers will need to understand the marketers language and will need to be able to quote the research, to point to the case studies and understand the objectives of brand positioning, return on marketing investment and the various measures that the success or otherwise of a campaign is judged on.
The printer will need to do their own research, calling on the expertise of supplier-partners, the resources of the industry’s media (both in print and whatever sector the client is in) and they need to understand the industry’s past by checking out the library at St Bride’s say.
If the economy is going to go into recession as seems increasingly likely, then printers need to be prepared. Now is the time to consider what it is they are selling. And the most powerful tool they can be selling today is about innovation and ideas. This is what is in short supply because innovation comes from making new connections between experiences, technologies and knowledge. Designers today have little experience, do not understand print technologies and lack the knowledge.
Printers on the other hand have this in abundance. This is the all too frequently untapped resource that will stimulate the new products and applications that the industry depends on for its future. It is no coincidence that many large packaging companies have customer experience centres to stimulate the connections that lead to new products. There are too few commercial printers with any similar set up. That needs to change and quickly. The printers that cannot do this, that are only at the receiving end of the PDF, will become less and less relevant to their customers. Because ultimately print is only a minor part of what those customers are buying.
Explore more...
MORE FROM THE MAGAZINE