The apprenticeship has dried up

There are too few apprentices joining the industry, posing a problem for print and sparking ideas for how to overcome the recruitment problem.

The apprenticeship system has failed the printing industry. The industry is not attracting the youngsters it needs to replace those that have left skilled roles in print, a factor that has been made worse by the impact of Covid, the closure of many printers and the reduction in print capacity by many more. 

The industry has relied on a flow of new blood through family ties and close friends for many generations and is not unique in this. But the flow has been staunched. Sons are not following fathers into print, let alone daughters. This has created problems because print, with a few exceptions, has never really had to go into the wider world to attract talent and does not have the links into careers offices, schools and colleges to replace these informal networks.

Some print businesses have built links with local schools via careers teachers and are known to take on youngsters. Where the teachers have some idea of the business and industry they are suggesting to the school leaver, there will be greater encouragement and support. And where the nearby printing company is a substantial employer, schools are more likely to view the industry in a favourable light. Unfortunately most print businesses are small, too small to be on the radar of the careers department.

There are apprentices out there, the BPIF will have around 200 on its books and is the largest training organisation in the country. Some of these were featured in the recent National Apprenticeship Week. However, in an industry employing 89,000 around 2,000 new entrants a year would be needed to maintain that number if careers span a 40-year working life. Not all jobs are skilled, not all jobs need apprenticeship training. But the numbers being trained fall well short of what would be necessary to keep the skills base at a steady level. Currently the BPIF lists 19 apprentice vacancies on its website, admittedly this is a long way from comprehensive and many more can be found via Google or local Job Centres. But not enough to replace the skills and experience that is retiring.

This is not a problem that is unique to the UK. It spans the developed world to a greater or lesser degree. Nobody has discovered the answer. The printing industry is considered too manual and the industry itself too traditional, and in decline. Awareness of the real state of the industry is sparse.

Technology helps because litho press operators no longer need to understand chemistry to balance inks, rollers, blankets and fount solutions to prevent scumming. They have no need to appreciate mechanics to solve on press problems of feeding, marking or doubling which had to be sorted through application of a spanner. These are functions that the modern press will solve on its own, or at least alert an operator to the need for maintenance when an engineer can be called in.

The advent of green button technology for digital presses and finishing equipment has ended the need to understand paper which was so crucial to the proper running of a folder that apprentices might spend their first indentured year fanning and gaining the intuitive knowledge of paper that skilled journeymen had.

In short the apprenticeship has been changed from a way of learning a skilled trade to training to carry out a function. At the same time, new skills based around computer technology, programming and data analysis, are needed to ensure the seamless flow of information around a factory, to automate workflows, to link smoothly to customers and to extract data about the condition of machinery to the margin earned on a job. This is not something that a 16-year-old school leaver should be doing.

Indeed more and more printers are recognising that 16-year-old school leavers, the traditional apprentice, are not what the print industry needs. All too often there are tales of new recruits turning up well after the working day has started, failing to turn up at all and lacking the appreciation and discipline needed for work. Any 16-year-old with any ability will stay on for sixth form or some form of higher education. The days when printers would take on youngsters even without conventional academic qualifications seem to have passed. 

This is not a universal reaction. Some company owners, perhaps remembering their own youth, are willing to give those without formal qualifications a chance. As technology pervades the industry there is less opportunity for a recruitment policy like this.

The question now is where does the new blood come from. It is a question that print associations have been grappling with without huge success. There is a defined modern apprenticeship which tells the recruit and their parents what to expect. Once inside the business there can be further organised and recognised training qualifications right to the equivalent of degree level. But the challenge is to get the talent through the door. 

There are no UK print colleges offering the sort of hands on training that the London College/School of Printing, Watford College and others around the country used to provide. Even day release has gone. Training is internal with contact with tutors taking place via Zoom or Teams. The apprentice will work in the business for most of the time, with 20% of the learners’s time to be spent on off the job training.

Because the challenge is of attracting youngsters is so difficult,  Some companies find that it can be better to concentrate on an age group that is slightly older and more mature. Pureprint and Precision Proco both employ many seasonal workers to cope with the volume of orders handled towards the end of the year. Those that show a broader interest in the business they are working for and who demonstrate and the right aptitude can get a figurative tap on the shoulder. 

“We approach those with the right attitude,” says Precision Proco CEO Gary Peeling. They are offered permanent jobs in the first instance and then training so that they can move into skilled positions across the business. “The fact that our manufacturing floor in Dagenham is 60-70% female reflects this. It works and is successful for us,” he says.

Others have risen to fill managerial roles in quality control. (“She started here packing calendars”) and supervisor positions. “This is a great benefit to the business,” he says. “We need to tell the story about what is possible in print much better than we have.

“There’s the group of young people who have been disenfranchised from the academic system, perhaps through dyslexia, that can find they are comfortable in process roles. Print by and large is well paid with opportunities for overtime. And they can progress through the factory if that is what they want. For us having eight GCSEs is not necessary.”

The company will stage a workshop inviting potential recruits gleaned from schools or Job Centres to identify which look like they might have the right stuff for print. 

“Then again, perhaps we should be looking at an older person, someone in their 30s or 40s looking to get back into machinery roles having worked in a warehouse or as a delivery driver and wanting something more rewarding. We’re now thinking of something along those lines, again pointing out that there’s a chance of progression within the industry. And academic qualifications are not necessary.”

That is true across the industry. Many businesses are owned and run by teams that started out on the shopfloor as apprentices. “I was an apprentice and a number of the management team are former apprentices,” says Hobbs the Printers managing director Graham Bromley. “Apprenticeships are a long established, well proven way to develop staff. But taking on people straight from school is a challenge and there is a high drop out rate. It is better if they have worked in the business for a while.”

There is a wide discrepancy in how apprentices are recruited, some companies emphasising the role, some their business, some the potential applicant. The  academic qualifications required will also vary.

The modern apprentice joins one of three tracks: prepress operative, press operative or post press operative. There are also apprenticeships for non production roles. The duration of each course is two years, leading to a Level 3 qualification.

The BPIF has set out the details in a freshly designed training prospectus for the print and graphics communication industry. It sets out the different options on offer, stressing the variety of flexible learning options that can be tailored to the requirements of the apprentice and the business taking them on. 

BPIF training managing director Karly Lattimore says: “The print and graphics communications industry is constantly evolving, and it is vital that we provide training and development opportunities to help our employers stay competitive.

“Our new prospectus is designed to meet the diverse needs of the industry and help individuals and businesses thrive in an ever changing landscape.”

It will take more than a nicely designed brochure to turn the tide.