The throw of the dice

Board games are booming as enthusiasts turn away from digital play to personal and social interaction represented by the traditional and not so traditional card or board game. How can UK printers win a place at the table?

In cities and towns across the country, young adults gather in cafes and bars, sit down around a table, shake a pair of dice and move a token or miniature figure around a brightly coloured board. These board game cafes have sprung up across the country, from Plymouth to Norwich, Southampton to Edinburgh. In an age when video games like Grand Theft Auto, League of Legends and Counterstrike have made the video games industry larger than the film industry, traditional table games are flourishing. They might not be the same favourites as 50 years ago, but perhaps in reaction to the ubiquitous nature of the digital screen, games played with friends or family are as popular as ever. 

The games have changed. There are card based games, games that link to celebrity or television shows, fantasy games, trivial games, action games – and the list goes on.

A new generation is discovering the joy of these ever more intricate games involving a board, playing pieces, cards, box, tokens, and rules. All of which need to be printed.

A recent report about the board games market put the industry size at $13.75 billion and growing at 13.7% a year, reaching $30.93 billion by 2028. Other table top games, like the staggeringly successful Warhammer franchise, created and owned by Games Workshop, are not included in this figure. Warhammer uses beautifully crafted and painted figurines to fight table top battles in a fantasy realm.

These are sold through shops with the worlds supported by rule books, magazines and even a book publishing imprint for a series of novels. It is a business with a revenue of £350 million and is expanding into new geographic markets as well as creating new fantasy worlds to host its games. There is a deliberate policy of never trying to depict real life either now or in the past. Games Workshop tries to source as much as possible from UK suppliers, but keeps schtumm about who those suppliers are and in turn the suppliers do not talk about their customer. 

It is not the only success story for the UK in the games world. At one time Waddington Games was a successful adjunct of the print and packaging group with the UK licence for Monopoly, and owning Cluedo, Totopoly and a host of others.

Towards the end of the millennium an Ipswich typesetting and design company San Serif owned by John Pryke acquired the rights to Trivial Pursuit in 1983, when Pryke was just 29 years old. The production demands led to the acquisition of the ailing WS Cowells business and Serif Cowells kept pace with the sensational demand for this game and for another hit game, Pictionary. There was also innovation: the company that Serif initially outsourced production to had to develop a four-fold game board for example. At its peak the business was employing around 400 staff to meet orders from across Europe.

As demand for Trivial Pursuit and its numerous spin off editions tailed off at the end of the decade, Pryke acquired the distribution rights to launch Nintendo’s games console in the UK. While that arrangement could not last, Pryke remained involved in the game sector until his death two years ago. 

It seems that once a board gamer always a board gamer and those that play board games like to design board games based on that experience. This is certainly the case for Butler Printing where Robert Butler has developed his hobby into a business and is producing board games, albeit in small numbers, at the long established family print business in Sheffield. 

“I worked at the company in my 20s,” he says, “then at 1ClickPrint. And I have always been into board game design, launching a project in 2015 through a Kickstarter campaign.”

The crowd funding network, more than anything else, including the pandemic, is responsible for the flourishing of new board games and the from there the steep rise in interest in playing the games. Across the world crowd funding has raised billions of dollars to help develop new games. The idea of the game is explained on the site and a goal is set for the amount of money to be raised. For some this is enough to create a few prototypes and a first batch of games, others are more ambitious and set their sights on funding long production runs requiring much more investment. 

There is generally a lag of several years between introducing the concept on the crowd funding site, gaining the supporters, testing hand made prototypes and refining the game play, repeating this process and then committing to some level of production and a commercial launch, after allowing for an extended print production cycle. Backers are enticed by the offer of extras that will not be in the commercial version when launched and by the idea that they spotted the next big thing in games.

At the same time the publisher does not want to be in a position where the game suddenly takes off, sells out and there is a three-month delay before new stock can get into the shops, by which time the excitement may have cooled. 

The risk is that unless that goal is reached, nobody parts with any money and the game developer has nothing. It is far better, Butler explains, to pitch low and over achieve than to fail to secure the necessary funding. 

Butler was ready to move to the next step, booking a 25m2 stand at the NEC for Games Expo, the UK’s largest event. “But the show was coming closer and the Chinese print company we had engaged had not delivered. We faced having to go to the show with no actual stock to sell,” he says. In desperation he turned to 1ClickPrint in Sheffield where he had been working and somehow created 150 units for the event, figuring out how to produce some of the needed items in the heat of the moment.

It also sparked something else. There will have been others in his situation as an independent game developer needing only a short production run, too few to be of real importance to the Chinese printers that dominate board game production, too small too for the few European printers in the market. And those that want to raise money on a crowd funding platform no longer have to set sky high targets for overseas production.

“We can make it viable for publishers and game designers to have 50-100 units, and this has become a successful area of the market for us,” he says.

“There are also people that do not want to go to China at all, which can lead to larger orders: we did a run of 5,000 units for one of these. Generally though with a game that needs a six-fold board, hand wrapping of the box and so on, 500 units is the limit.”

It is more than simply printing the board, the play cards, box wrap and tokens that can be die cut are essential along with the tray to hold the components. Ever more intricate characters are needed to represent each player in the game. Monopoly’s top hat, battleship, dog and so on have become monsters, warriors, astronauts, sailing ships, steam trains and many, many more. The intricacies of injection moulding these is one reason for production in China and the reason that long production runs are necessary.

Butler continues: “I remember the first wave of colour laser printers. It would take three to four minutes to generate a four-colour page and the quality wasn’t brilliant. Now 80-90% of what we do is on a digital press. Something similar is happening in 3D printing. There is a rapid rate of development.

“Our idea is to have a hub for production on demand of board games, including the miniatures, and with the capacity to produce 100 sets a day. We think this will be a workable business.

“We are already one of the few companies that can produce prototypes that are 99% accurate to the finished product,” he says. “So we produce prototypes for the larger publishers and deliver a short production run for smaller companies.”

It means that Butler is dealing with some Chinese suppliers. “It does not make sense for us to produce more than 2,000 units.”

The barrier is not about quality, even if Chinese quality can be suspect at times. It is simply about cost, aided by the availability of Chinese companies to employ armies of hand workers able to assemble the components needed for a game and to pack them into the box designed for the purpose. As labour rates increase in China, that element of the work will migrate to lower cost countries elsewhere in south east Asia. 

Freight costs from Asia are not going down in the long term and there are sustainability and human rights issues that hang over Chinese production. These concerns are already prompting book publishers to look again at production closer to readers in Europe, the UK and US. Board game publishers may follow suit. 

The problem is that there is a lack of capacity in Europe for large or even regional scale production. This is not a problem for card led games where there is ample capacity for producing standard playing cards, but few have capacity for the box and board making, the counters and tokens let alone the miniatures needed.

Automation and robot pick and pack technology may help in future, but for the moment the European market is in the hands of a limited number of suppliers: Belgian group Cartamundi, LudoFact from Germany and Fabryka Cart from Poland. The latter is probably the newest, growing from producing playing cards into board games proper. It reckons to have capacity for 30 million products, not all games, a year, 200 staff and a production floor led by a Koenig & Bauer B1 Rapida, capable of applying the UV varnish, die cutting and box production including magnetic catch and a line dedicated to playing card production that simultaneously produce the boxes, packs the playing cards to cut back on manual labour.

LudoFact is a larger business with output of 17 million board games for 200 publishers a year from its main plant in Jettingen, close to Stuttgart, and from other sites close by that it has acquired in recent years. It too uses five-colour Speedmaster as well as Indigo digital print.

Like LudoFact, Fabryka Cart promotes sustainability, installing solar panels and harvesting rainwater and cuts down on unnecessary use of paper by adopting digital communications and has planted a wildflower meadow at the factory. Cartamundi’s main board game factory is in Waterford, today producing Monopoly and Trivial Pursuit among others. It too has capacity for around 17 million games a year from a 22,500m2 facility running a five-colour plus coat litho press, supported by a two-colour machine. 

The assembly area adjacent to the press hall houses different box making lines with a maximum output of 500,000 units a week. In addition the company has its own injection moulding equipment on site.

Beyond these there are sites which like Butler Print handle small batch production or prototypes and many that can produce card games. Others will surely follow as production in China comes under greater scrutiny. Manufacturers there cannot offer the FSC papers (at least not legally) that publishers want because there simply are not the forests in China and neighbouring countries that are certified. 

Supply lines are becoming a risk that publishers need to consider. “Can European printers win market share? Their costs needs to be competitive against China, not necessarily against the production cost, but with shipping costs and customs duties included,” says Cedric Delobelle, co-founder of the All About Games specialist consultancy. He has 15 years’ experience in games production and set up the business a couple of years ago. The timing seems to have been perfect. “We have been growing at 200% a year because people need help. They do not understand manufacturing,” he says.

There is a steeply climbing interest in sustainable production, sparked, he says, during the pandemic. This puts China at a disadvantage because there is almost no FSC paper available in the country. But it’s not always clear where the benefits lie. “There is a lot of interest in using bamboo as a substitute for plastics, but a lot of water is needed to cultivate bamboo which is an adverse effect and people do not want shrink wrap plastic. But if just six units are damaged in a batch of 15,000 games, the environmental cost of replacing those games is greater than the harm from the plastic. It’s about perceptions.”

Production in China may be hit too by extensions to the EUTR rules which have to date prevented import into Europe of timber and timber products that lack a proper chain of custody to prove that the imports have been sourced from well managed forests. Print is now to be included in the regulation, increasing the risks for games publishers from printing in Asia.

When coupled with the environmental impact of over production and shipping, this can help localise production, as the marketing from LudoFact and Fabryka Cart suggests. However, this comes at a price that publishers may not be willing to pay. Localised production to the UK can increase costs by 20%, says Delobelle. Some may be willing to pay this premium, but if retail price is not to be pushed beyond the psychologically important £100 mark, margins will be hit. Games that would sell for six or seven times their production price can only achieve a four-times multiple.

Material costs have been rising too, forced up by post pandemic shortages and energy costs. Publishers have been looking at ways to reduce costs: black core board used to stop show through on playing cards shifts to less expensive blue core board and 280gsm material can become 230gsm. They also want certainty over pricing says Delobelle. “European printers will not guarantee a price but Chinese printers do – at least for a 30-day fixed period. We’d like to see that come into Europe,” he says. 

The European companies have a stronger delivery ethos, even if turnaround times can be lengthy especially when materials can be difficult to source. Those have now returned to normal as materials shortages have eased. Another Chinese attribute, that of agreeing with the customer at all times, can lead to friction if this aspect is not understood by the publisher. Deliveries can be delayed, sometimes with massive consequences for publishers as Robert Butler discovered. In turn this can have implications for cashflow for a new publisher.

Table top games take other forms.  For example, Dungeons and Dragons is a role playing game that needs figurines and an extensive rule book and printed charts, but little by the way of gaming boards. There are many, many card games from the likes of Uno to Earthborne which bills itself as “a sustainably produced, customisable adventure card game set in the far future”.

Games can be instructive, even snakes and ladders was conceived in ancient India to drum some kind of moral thinking into young children. Today such games can be part of a corporate training scheme, which is how Hayman Creative in Nottingham found itself producing board games. “We had a call from someone asking if we could produce a health and safety themed Snakes and Ladders board game for them. We agreed,” says Barry Hayman. 

With time on his hands during lockdown he put this new found ability of the company’s website and tapped into a seam of work that might otherwise have passed him by. A trickle of inquiries followed, then a stream of work followed, boosted by word of mouth and social media.

“Understanding the market has been an organic process for us. We had the range of equipment and skills to be able to produce short run board games, we can advise on how to present their artwork because they have no experience on the print side of things,” he says.

Hayman is not aiming to take on Chinese or even European producers, the market is strictly about proof of concept and prototypes. A run of 50 units of an educational game for Birmingham University and 100 for a school is enough. “We are good from single examples through to 100 units. We struggle beyond that,” he says. He struggles too with producing the bespoke rigid boxes that the games are packed in. “We would be happy to partner with a box provider, someone that can supply five prototypes.” 

And prototypes are the mainstay of a business stream that did not exist for Hayman Creative before the lockdown period. There were  a lot of people with time on their hands designing a board game, he explains. “Those calls have increased, so too the calls from people wanting to create a highly personalised version of Monopoly, which is possible because the game is out of copyright. We can go well beyond the template for such games,” he explains. 

He is currently working with a developer on how to perfect an idea for a metal detecting game with interactive working detectors. “We are having to research all sorts of different options to try to find ways to produce this,” says Hayman.

Others are working with other start up games publishers that began during Covid as something to pass the time and has grown from a side hustle into a structured business. The stand out example of this is Format Games, started by Radio 1 DJ and presenter Matt Edmondson. It has a number of successes under its belt. On the home page of the company’s website, it says: “During lockdown, rather than learning Ancient Greek or hoarding loo roll, Radio 1 DJ and TV presenter Matt Edmondson used his creative energy and previous experience of designing games to come up with new ideas. Along the way, he also taught himself graphic and packaging design and copywriting and learnt about the games’ manufacturing process — everything needed to bring the games to market independently.”