Frank Jäger says that the largest independent games printer in Europe is investing in a future where the environmental impact of production becomes key concern for publishers.
Frank Jäger will tell you that Monopoly is not his favourite board game and that in his opinion it is not even a great game. Jäger ought to know. He is a game aficionado and knows his way around a playing board or deck of cards.
He also sees far more of them than almost anyone else. He heads product development at LudoFact, Europe’s largest independent printer of board games capable of delivering 80,000 packed, wrapped and stacked games a day. It is not a big field. There’s capacity in Poland and the Netherlands, Spain and Italy as well as Germany either on a smaller scale or part of larger groups. Nor is LudoFact a small enterprise. There are five production sites including one in the US, a joint venture in Czech Republic and three in Germany. Its US plant opened in 2017 with a $13 million investment. In the same year LudoFact acquired digital printer Friedmann Print Data Solutions followed in 2019 by Höhn Display and Packaging in Ulm, a company that produces folding boxes, PoS displays and laminated corrugated board.
The group also includes a related green energy generation business that was set up at the same time as LudoFact was founded 28 years ago. At that point green energy was a minority interest, no longer. The business generates enough renewable energy to power a town with 130,000 inhabitants or to power a factory printing board games and the associated tasks that are needed for games.
“As soon as you approach the games market you have to know how to laminate, how to die cut and punch and you need a lot of manual labour,” Jäger says. It is that labour element that means production in China can be so much cheaper than production in Europe.
Cost is not everything and with a greater awareness of sustainability among publishers, change is afoot. He explains: “The pandemic has had an impact with people looking closely at their supply chains with a lot of reevaluation of where they should produce their game. The eco angle is where we can score.”
Some publishers are already adjusting their designs to remove extraneous packaging. However, it will be more of a challenge to eliminate plastic from the components that make up a game. China has a huge advantage in this regard. Costs of a master for injection moulding in that country are 20% of costs in Germany. But the migration from plastic opens the door to the use of alternatives, bamboo or other materials bound together by a resin. Jäger points out that this still uses a plastic as a bonding agent, making recycling difficult.
“There’s a move from oil derived plastic to bio plastics, but we want to get rid of plastic completely. Bio plastic is step forward, but it’s not the end of the journey.”
As a truly green alternative, LudoFact has invested in laser cutting to be able to produce playing tokens from wood. “It’s a sustainable material, and a reliable source for gamers. Some have moved from plastic based on fossil oil to bioplastic, but we wanted to get rid of plastic entirely,” he explains.
This means some smart use of moulded pulp and cardboard engineering to replace plastic trays for customers that want to demonstrate eco consciousness. “It is,” he says, “a key driving force for the business. we are not there yet, but it’s gaining traction.”
As well as cutting carbon through renewable energy, LudoFact ensures that any trade suppliers (for rules leaflets and so on) are no more than 200km from the main factory near Augsburg in Bavaria to reduce impacts. Its HP Indigo is used to produce card packs more effectively than litho print up to runs of 2,500 sets of 55 cards each. The quality of digital print means the company can now combine litho and digital in the same set as well as producing sets which are completely unique in their mix of cards.
When he first saw digital printing Jäger recalls he doubted whether it would ever reach the quality needed. “Now we use digital to print for start ups, for test runs and to introduce a game at a show because the quality is so much better,” he explains. “But we don’t think that 3D printing will come down in cost and effectiveness in the same way as digital printing.”
The company has invested in its first robot, designed to load finished games to a pallet rather than to fill trays with game components. This is where manual labour is still important. The dexterity of human fingers to pick up and place the combination of cards, playing pieces, tokens and playing board that make up the game remains paramount, particularly where runs are relatively low. It makes sense to automate the completion of a Monopoly set because of the numbers produced each day, but the start up time for a robot assisted system is longer than it would take a team of bench hands to complete the 5,000 sets in a run, says Jäger.
“And every game is different with a different mix of components every time. Humans are still far more adaptable than robots.”
This does not mean there is no automation. Cards will move straight from the digital press into a punching machine to deliver ready to pack card sets in a two touch process. It would like to go further and has been trying to develop an automated cutting machine, but not yet to the point of application.
It’s an indication that LudoFact is confident that demand for table top games is not going to disappear. Turnover has increased by double digits in recent years thanks to changing habits imposed by Covid-19 and now a cost of living crisis. “People didn’t go out in the pandemic and bought games and puzzles instead.
“When video games were introduced in the 1990s, traditional games industry was very nervous about the threat. In the end there was a dip, but only by 2-3%. Video games are missing the social company that board games have. We do not expect demand for games to go away.”
There is demand from a wave of new publishers with crowd funded ideas, LudoFact receives around 360 idea submissions a year. It can work with these games to tweak the design and packaging to fit the constraints of the process and so save the publisher unnecessary expense. It will remain cheaper to print in China, but the service element may be missing and delivery times will inevitably be less reliable as supply chains become increasingly fragile.
The consequence will be a return to more local production with less environmental impact, availability of FSC paper and no human rights questions. As that happens, LudoFact will be in the game.