No one buys from someone they don’t know, so why do marketers invest so little in their brand?
When Print Business decided to ditch the polywrap and embrace naked mailing in the latter half of 2020 we thought long and hard about how the back cover would look. Not to put too fine a point on it, we wanted our innovative back cover to have the same top drawer design as the rest of the magazine.
To achieve this we designed ads for the two companies that we thought would have the vision to see that strong design on the outside of a magazine with a long desk life would have massive impact. Our proviso was that they had to stick to the design. Both wanted to snap it up. Both were more than happy about the design stipulation. One had deeper pockets.
After about two years Kodak asked if the design could be changed. Alarm bells rang but we agreed to look at what they wanted. It was really quite different. The new ad was spraymounted on to a copy of the magazine and a video call booked.
We only had one point to make. The Kodak slogan ‘Print That Pays’ is to print what Nike’s ‘Just Do It’ is to sportswear. That impact of that message with one of the world’s most recognisable logos, on the desks of the most important people in print… what would be gained by change?
It wasn’t a long call and the original ad is still there. The small print has been refreshed but the gold logo and appealing catchline are doing the same job as the golden arches and ‘I’m lovin’ it’.
This is why display advertising is worth its weight in gold. Keeping the brand in front of the customer when they are not in the market means it is front of mind when they decide that investment is needed.
But it takes time and isn’t cheap. And that is sort of the point. Look at the money spent on luxury goods ads. Cars, watches, jewellery, perfume… only a tiny fraction of those who see those ads can afford them. The ads are there to reassure those who can afford them that they made the right choice and to inspire those who could perhaps stretch to them to make the leap.
(And it works – we’ve been to hundreds of factories over the years and we see the cars parked next to the reception, from Bentleys in Barking to Lamborghinis in Letchworth.)
Print is largely a luxury product. The trust it instills is incomparable to anything the digital world can offer. Customers are irritated by the tyranny of email. Instagram influencers are losing their audience as the once charming app is flooded with low value ads. Online ads have a truly pitiful ROI.
So the pendulum swings and print is enjoying a moment in the sun. However, print has been absent from budgets for so long that the moment of inspiration in the marketing meeting is overshadowed by those signing off the POs.
And here’s the rub. Products that truly deserve a champagne celebration are allocated a beer budget. Products that have had tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of pounds or more poured into their development sit on the shelf because no one knows they are there.
It’s all very well splashing out on a lavish launch party, inviting everyone you can think of who might buy this fantastic product – plus the press who will write about it. Those who turn up have a good time, promise to seriously consider the excellent product and wander off into the night. The hangovers the next day are borne with good grace while reading the follow up email. Then a few days later another follow up email remains unread.
The trade press duly writes about the very good product. There may be a sprinkling of display ads but these peter out. More follow up emails remain unread. The product sits forlornly on the shelf. No one dare mention the ROI of the launch event.
There comes a point where Sales demands some marketing support. Marketing suggests some ads, perhaps with the message ProductX Promises Profit in big type, a paragraph of what it does in small type, a prominent company logo and a QR code to the webpage where all the specs are.
Not good enough, says Sales. Take everything on the webpage and put it in the ad. Tell the whole world everything there is to know and have lots of pictures, especially the one of the really cool button.
Finance looks up and asks how much it’s going to cost and who’s paying for it. It is decided that just one ad will be placed in all the magazines. Because ads are expensive and no one knows who has seen them. The flurry of ads with no coherent design or consistent message or even focal point does not elicit much reponse. They are deemed to have failed, a waste of money.
While all of this has been going on, there are companies who have invested in long term advertising doing steady trade and keeping the dispatch department busy. They are always in front of their customers, with their short and memorable messages. Perhaps a picture of a new product. But definitely no shoehorning of information and specifications into the ad. That’s what the website is for. Or better still for printers, that’s what the brochure is for.
If you’re thinking about the possibility of inkjet, which way round do you think about it? Google inkjet and see what comes up? Or does your eye land on some gold paper on your desk with Print That Pays on it? Ah yes, Kodak. They do inkjet don’t they? Let’s start there.