A report claims government can be more efficient without the use of paper, and Two Sides has leaped into action.
TWO SIDES HAS ATTACKED A think tank report calling for further use of digital technology and communication by government. While there is little remarkable in the ‘Smarter, Better, Faster, Stronger’ report produced by the Policy Exchange think tank, it does call for the elimination of paper based communication between government departments.
Its author, Chris Yiu, head of Digital Government at Policy Exchange, would also like to see communications with the general public become digital by default and only rely on paper in extremis. The result of adopting its recommendations would be “significant savings in terms of time, paper, money and carbon”. It is not claiming that digital is good, paper is bad. Indeed, the report acknowledges that paper is comfortable to read and easy to annotate. While many would point out that tablets and electronic ink are not as easy to annotate and read as Policy Exchange would like to think, the tide is running in that direction.
IT USES SOME EXTREME EXAMPLES to state its case, without verification. The DVLA in Swansea has one of the biggest government print works, but scarcely converts more than 100 tonnes of paper a day as the arrival of two articulated trucks filled with letters and paperwork might suggest. Nor does a claim that the Crown Prosecution Service prints out 1 million sheets of paper a day, that is it uses 1,000 tonnes of paper a day which would be good news for paper suppliers if entirely accurate.
As Two Sides represents the interests of the paper industry, it is hardly surprising that it has condemned the report. “In the opinion of Two Sides, the report appears to ignore the clear choice that consumers express for paper based media for many types of documentation and the needs of millions of citizens without digital access,” the organisation says. On the contrary the report deals with this issue, first saying that as the non enfranchised die off, the problem will become less, that charities and commercial entities could help those unable to use the internet to do so and thirdly it recommends some kinds of incentive to encourage digital adoption.
HOWEVER, POLICY EXCHANGE, WHILE swallowing the statistics about smart phone growth and tablet use, ignores the lamentable broadband and wireless coverage in many parts of the country which must hobble its belief that happy citizens will be digital citizens.
It also concentrates on functional communications between government and people. Hence the idea of a paperless health service is fine for the communication of treatments, records, drugs and so on, and Xerox is encouraging this type of thinking, the prescription ignores the thousands of patient information leaflets that must remain on paper.
VERY LITTLE OF THE REPORT IS directly concerned with paper, more is about borrowing ideas from digitally based businesses like Amazon as a way to open up government. Its recommendations in this direction could spawn new publication products and therefore support print.
The report collects the clichés about the benefits of technology, makes some errors in its sprinkling of computing terminology, but makes sense even if its claimed £70 billion saving by 2020 is headline grabbing rather than practical.
One of Two Sides complaints is that paper is more effective and that print documents receive more attention. This has been tacitly recognised by Policy Exchange. The report was printed by Heron, Dawson & Sawyer in Clerkenwell and sells for £10.