The printing industry has weathered the storm, says Charles Jarrold, BPIF chief executive, addressing the online Print Power conference. Confidence is up and the presses are turning. Supply chain issues aside, normality appears to be returning. But he was addressing an online conference.
Under normal circumstances this conference would have taken place at Stationers’ Hall, (though this is out of operation at the moment due to restoration work). Things are not back to normal while Covid-19 transmission rates remain high and hospitals clogged with severe cases of infection. Work from home is still encouraged and the whiff of further lockdowns or quasi lockdowns is in the air.
It may be, however, that we are in the eye of the storm, not through to the calm on the other side. Furlough has helped the printing industry retain jobs that would otherwise have been lost, but a return to furlough is impossible now to contemplate.
In any case it is impossible this close to the event to decide what its impact has been, whether in fact print has weathered the storm. In the immediate aftermath of an asteroid striking the planet hundreds of millions of years ago, one dinosaur might have turned to his colleague saying “Did you hear that? We survived that impact.” It was not the impact or explosion that did for the dinosaurs, it was the aftermath, the vast amounts of dust that entered the atmosphere to block out the sun, to kill the vegetation that many creatures ate and then the meat eaters who were used to feasting on the vegetarians who had already starved to death.
This is not to decry Charles Jarrold. It certainly appears that print has come through the pandemic, strengthened if anything by the experiences of the last two years. Sales of books have remained high and print’s effectiveness in cutting through the digital noise and communicating a message is appreciated more than ever, as the Print Power conference, online or not, made abundantly clear.
It will only be by looking back in ten years’ time that the full impact of the pandemic on print can be assessed and what the long lasting impact of pandemic might have been.
This does not mean printers should return to pre 2019 behaviours expecting a return to the same sort of reality. It may happen. This period will then be a minor ripple in history, not an inflexion point to question and change the direction we are headed. All commentators will agree that the period has accelerated change even if there is no consensus on what that change was going to be.
It is perhaps instructive to look back to the banking crisis and what happened then. At that point print was on a high. Sales were at their peak: Heidelberg’s record year for press production was 2006 for example. Paper companies were still investing in mills and machines to make web offset papers. Computerisation, computer to plate and digital printing were all helping to make print easier to specify and improving quality. Then came 2008 and it all changed.
Among the machines Heidelberg sold in vast quantities in 2006 was the Speedmaster 52. Three years later sales of B3 litho presses had slowed to a trickle. That format had been superseded by digital printing. It was not apparent at the time.
Also in 2006, the internet was taking greater hold. The technology was more mature and grounded than in the run up to the dotcom explosion just a few years earlier. Network connectivity was better, website design had improved, Paypal was on the street and deep in a lab in California a team was working on the iPhone. Printing would never bounce back to 2006 levels.
In print terms, Vistaprint was taking baby steps and a number of other companies were making tentative moves into the online purchase of print. And the years since that crash have been about the rise of online printers, about smartphones, 4G and 5G connectivity and ever richer online experiences. Online print is very much more than business cards and photobooks.
Paper companies are no longer investing in new capacity in papers for printing or newsprint. Instead that capacity is being converted into production of packaging grades, folding cartons, boxboards and especially corrugated.
If these developments were missed by the industry in 2008, it is surely too soon to make judgements and draw conclusions about a post pandemic period in 2021.
Most of the companies we spoke to for this issue are employing fewer people than two years ago, yet are producing the same if not more output. Automation is being harnessed to improve productivity and effectiveness. A number of printers are installing robotic arms and more to replace non value adding repetitive tasks. Robots are going to become commonplace in printers, if not essential.
If we could look at the industry some ten years into the future we will see robot handling everywhere, not just for removing sections from a folder and arranging them artfully on a pallet. Robot arms will be loading book blocks into binders, delivering those pallets of folded sections to stitching or binding lines, boxing products and storing them. Automation will be replacing the need for people. It is happening today. As author William Gibson explained “The future is already here – it’s just not evenly distributed.”
The print business in 2031 will supply every customer with a carbon invoice as well as a financial one. Companies are already starting to think in terms of carbon impact and are measuring their processes in this way. These Scope 1 and Scope 2 measures are straightforward to assess. The real work is about Scope 3, where suppliers provide data about their emissions and suppliers are selected on these grounds rather than by quality or immediate price. Again this is starting to happen now, though is not yet ubiquitous. The printers that aim to weather the next part of the storm will be ready to supply a carbon figure for customers. It may be that by 2031 they will need to deliver a carbon figure to the Carbon Tax Department at HMRC.
The print specifier in 2031 is today at university or in school, absorbing lessons about the environment and ecology that will have an indelible effect on their lives. The Gen Z cohort is going to be immeasurably influential in shaping their world for the better. It is sustainability all the way – they will simply have no choice.
There will be printed newspapers, though more expensive per copy than now and with a continuing decline in circulation. There will be printed magazines, possibly even more than today, though high volume titles will be fewer. High volumes of inserts, of promotional catalogues, or low value print, will have mutated into fewer higher value products that are relevant to readers.
Again this is already happening. How many companies are planning investment in new heatset web offset capacity? Or a newspaper press? The machine breakdown at Chantry a few weeks ago caused waves around the industry as the capacity to absorb the loss of one machine was not there in the country that practically invented high speed web offset. By 2030 that machine and its like could be cobwebbed. Ephemeral work will have vanished.
These are the dinosaur businesses, large unwieldy and unable because of their size to adapt to the new conditions. It’s not just in the UK. Prinovis has announced the gradual wind down of its super gravure and offset in Dresden before closing at the end of next year. And this comes hard on the heels of its equally vast Nuremberg plant closing this year. In France, Helio Corbeil closed as a gravure printing business, but is being reborn as a digital print business. It will be intriguing to see if this can succeed.
Twilight for the dinosaurs was also dawn for mammals, a new class of creature that was smaller, more agile and better adapted to survive, if not an asteroid strike, then at least an ice age or two. The mammals of print are creating new ways of operating and are finding new applications and demand for print. By 2030 consumers will be used to specifying products that meets their individual requirements and print will be part of that process. One of the great successes of lockdown has been the greetings card, by virtue of necessity because high street retailers were closed. People are used to the proliferation of designs available on line, a far richer choice than in any high street outlet. The experience will have created a habit that is both ingrained and will leave purchasers with a taste for more. Online stores are limitless and production on demand means none of the waste that has restricted choice to generations of consumers. And print with the right approach is very much part of this.
Again some are purchasing wall art as well as new styles of photobook through web portals. In ten years’ time householders will be comfortable with creating their own look that is not about a different arrangement of the same products from Ikea or HomeSense, but will include custom design cushions, wall coverings, curtains and more. The T-shirt is the gateway drug to digitally printed patterned clothes. Companies like Printful enable designers to reach an audience of millions with apparel designs which is printed and produced to order. It is on its way to be a vast market with the seeds sewn for both creator and purchaser during this lockdown period.
These trends are only just getting underway. But the experience of lockdown has indeed compressed the learning curve for consumers. There is opportunity for the nimble printer, not for the dinosaur. In ten years’ time this is what weathering the storm will have looked like. It will not be about more of the same, but about changes in what is printed, how it is printed and, unless the printing industry is careful, who is printing it.
The dinosaurs did not know what hit them
The printing industry has weathered the storm, says Charles Jarrold, BPIF chief executive, addressing the online Print Power conference. Confidence is up and the presses are turning. Supply chain issues aside, normality appears to be returning. But he was addressing an online conference.
Under normal circumstances this conference would have taken place at Stationers’ Hall, (though this is out of operation at the moment due to restoration work). Things are not back to normal while Covid-19 transmission rates remain high and hospitals clogged with severe cases of infection. Work from home is still encouraged and the whiff of further lockdowns or quasi lockdowns is in the air.
It may be, however, that we are in the eye of the storm, not through to the calm on the other side. Furlough has helped the printing industry retain jobs that would otherwise have been lost, but a return to furlough is impossible now to contemplate.
In any case it is impossible this close to the event to decide what its impact has been, whether in fact print has weathered the storm. In the immediate aftermath of an asteroid striking the planet hundreds of millions of years ago, one dinosaur might have turned to his colleague saying “Did you hear that? We survived that impact.” It was not the impact or explosion that did for the dinosaurs, it was the aftermath, the vast amounts of dust that entered the atmosphere to block out the sun, to kill the vegetation that many creatures ate and then the meat eaters who were used to feasting on the vegetarians who had already starved to death.
This is not to decry Charles Jarrold. It certainly appears that print has come through the pandemic, strengthened if anything by the experiences of the last two years. Sales of books have remained high and print’s effectiveness in cutting through the digital noise and communicating a message is appreciated more than ever, as the Print Power conference, online or not, made abundantly clear.
It will only be by looking back in ten years’ time that the full impact of the pandemic on print can be assessed and what the long lasting impact of pandemic might have been.
This does not mean printers should return to pre 2019 behaviours expecting a return to the same sort of reality. It may happen. This period will then be a minor ripple in history, not an inflexion point to question and change the direction we are headed. All commentators will agree that the period has accelerated change even if there is no consensus on what that change was going to be.
It is perhaps instructive to look back to the banking crisis and what happened then. At that point print was on a high. Sales were at their peak: Heidelberg’s record year for press production was 2006 for example. Paper companies were still investing in mills and machines to make web offset papers. Computerisation, computer to plate and digital printing were all helping to make print easier to specify and improving quality. Then came 2008 and it all changed.
Among the machines Heidelberg sold in vast quantities in 2006 was the Speedmaster 52. Three years later sales of B3 litho presses had slowed to a trickle. That format had been superseded by digital printing. It was not apparent at the time.
Also in 2006, the internet was taking greater hold. The technology was more mature and grounded than in the run up to the dotcom explosion just a few years earlier. Network connectivity was better, website design had improved, Paypal was on the street and deep in a lab in California a team was working on the iPhone. Printing would never bounce back to 2006 levels.
In print terms, Vistaprint was taking baby steps and a number of other companies were making tentative moves into the online purchase of print. And the years since that crash have been about the rise of online printers, about smartphones, 4G and 5G connectivity and ever richer online experiences. Online print is very much more than business cards and photobooks.
Paper companies are no longer investing in new capacity in papers for printing or newsprint. Instead that capacity is being converted into production of packaging grades, folding cartons, boxboards and especially corrugated.
If these developments were missed by the industry in 2008, it is surely too soon to make judgements and draw conclusions about a post pandemic period in 2021.
Most of the companies we spoke to for this issue are employing fewer people than two years ago, yet are producing the same if not more output. Automation is being harnessed to improve productivity and effectiveness. A number of printers are installing robotic arms and more to replace non value adding repetitive tasks. Robots are going to become commonplace in printers, if not essential.
If we could look at the industry some ten years into the future we will see robot handling everywhere, not just for removing sections from a folder and arranging them artfully on a pallet. Robot arms will be loading book blocks into binders, delivering those pallets of folded sections to stitching or binding lines, boxing products and storing them. Automation will be replacing the need for people. It is happening today. As author William Gibson explained “The future is already here – it’s just not evenly distributed.”
The print business in 2031 will supply every customer with a carbon invoice as well as a financial one. Companies are already starting to think in terms of carbon impact and are measuring their processes in this way. These Scope 1 and Scope 2 measures are straightforward to assess. The real work is about Scope 3, where suppliers provide data about their emissions and suppliers are selected on these grounds rather than by quality or immediate price. Again this is starting to happen now, though is not yet ubiquitous. The printers that aim to weather the next part of the storm will be ready to supply a carbon figure for customers. It may be that by 2031 they will need to deliver a carbon figure to the Carbon Tax Department at HMRC.
The print specifier in 2031 is today at university or in school, absorbing lessons about the environment and ecology that will have an indelible effect on their lives. The Gen Z cohort is going to be immeasurably influential in shaping their world for the better. It is sustainability all the way – they will simply have no choice.
There will be printed newspapers, though more expensive per copy than now and with a continuing decline in circulation. There will be printed magazines, possibly even more than today, though high volume titles will be fewer. High volumes of inserts, of promotional catalogues, or low value print, will have mutated into fewer higher value products that are relevant to readers.
Again this is already happening. How many companies are planning investment in new heatset web offset capacity? Or a newspaper press? The machine breakdown at Chantry a few weeks ago caused waves around the industry as the capacity to absorb the loss of one machine was not there in the country that practically invented high speed web offset. By 2030 that machine and its like could be cobwebbed. Ephemeral work will have vanished.
These are the dinosaur businesses, large unwieldy and unable because of their size to adapt to the new conditions. It’s not just in the UK. Prinovis has announced the gradual wind down of its super gravure and offset in Dresden before closing at the end of next year. And this comes hard on the heels of its equally vast Nuremberg plant closing this year. In France, Helio Corbeil closed as a gravure printing business, but is being reborn as a digital print business. It will be intriguing to see if this can succeed.
Twilight for the dinosaurs was also dawn for mammals, a new class of creature that was smaller, more agile and better adapted to survive, if not an asteroid strike, then at least an ice age or two. The mammals of print are creating new ways of operating and are finding new applications and demand for print. By 2030 consumers will be used to specifying products that meets their individual requirements and print will be part of that process. One of the great successes of lockdown has been the greetings card, by virtue of necessity because high street retailers were closed. People are used to the proliferation of designs available on line, a far richer choice than in any high street outlet. The experience will have created a habit that is both ingrained and will leave purchasers with a taste for more. Online stores are limitless and production on demand means none of the waste that has restricted choice to generations of consumers. And print with the right approach is very much part of this.
Again some are purchasing wall art as well as new styles of photobook through web portals. In ten years’ time householders will be comfortable with creating their own look that is not about a different arrangement of the same products from Ikea or HomeSense, but will include custom design cushions, wall coverings, curtains and more. The T-shirt is the gateway drug to digitally printed patterned clothes. Companies like Printful enable designers to reach an audience of millions with apparel designs which is printed and produced to order. It is on its way to be a vast market with the seeds sewn for both creator and purchaser during this lockdown period.
These trends are only just getting underway. But the experience of lockdown has indeed compressed the learning curve for consumers. There is opportunity for the nimble printer, not for the dinosaur. In ten years’ time this is what weathering the storm will have looked like. It will not be about more of the same, but about changes in what is printed, how it is printed and, unless the printing industry is careful, who is printing it.
Explore more...