Plate traits

How do plates stack up when it comes to the environment? There was a time when whole rooms were devoted to chemistry and processors, but technology is making something of a clean sweep.

The era when the platemaking department at a printer could be accurately described as a devil’s kitchen because of the array of potent chemicals and manual processes needed to coat a lithographic plate before imaging and processing in an equally hellish chemical brew are, thankfully, long gone. The age of plate whirlers gave way to presensitised plates, then less harmful processing chemistry, involving innocuous sounding aqueous solutions. And more recently the industry has come to rely on plates that are directly imaged by laser, plates that need only rudimentary processing and some that need none at all.

On the journey there have been a number of false turns: the Dupont no process ablative plate being one and Creo’s promise of a reusable switchable polymer plate being another. All are searching for the ultimate printing plate, with environmental performance rising to the top of the list of requirements. Nobody would even consider creating a plate that turned the clock back in terms of processing chemistry. And there are interesting ideas in terms of printing plates that continue to swirl. A number of inkjet systems exist, some using barely modified Epson printers; others like the Glunz & Jensen or Dotworks, offering workable plates using inkjet imaging.

Processing is about fixing the image rather than removing a coating and thus creating some kind of waste. Presstek offers ablative technology where a plate needs only a wash to remove a microscopic layer detached from the plate by the platesetter’s laser. The technology works well in the company’s DI presses, but outside a handful of users, the company has failed to convince the bulk of the industry to make the change, at least in Europe. It is interesting that at Ipex Presstek introduced Aeon, a conventionally imaged and processsed plate, albeit in much reduced chemistry, with the idea of taking a little market share from the Big Three world producers.

The same problems are likely to befall the UK-led project to develop a reusable printing plate using a new type of high power laser. And any radical development from plate producers in Spain, Brazil or China will also face difficulties in reaching the market, even if they could navigate through the piles of patents that exist in this area. Many have been issued to the major manufacturers and describe new types of coating that can be used in reimageable plates and even the laboratory testing of these materials, but none are coming to a plate distributor near you just yet. Because just as important as the technology underlying any new plate is the ability to get it to market and to support early adopters in order to gain market acceptance. It will be very difficult to break the tri-opoly of Agfa, Fujifilm and Kodak. This is why VIM, Glunz & Jensen and so on are able to exist at the lower end of the market where volumes are not high and so do not affect the dominance of the large companies.

This is not to say there is any cartel nor any agreement to stick with existing products. Far from it. Even in a mature market like litho plates, new products are reaching the market, each with an ecological improvement over its predecessors. And the improvements are not restricted to the plate and processing at the print site, huge reductions in energy consumption, water use, and in the use of noxious chemicals have been made at the factories producing these plates. Agfa’s Leeds factory, once the showpiece Howson Algraphy plant, employs a fraction of the staff from the days when the Queen opened it, but equally it has a fraction of the environmental footprint.

The plant is now producing the Azura TS plate in order to meet steeply rising demand for Agfa’s chemistry-free plate. It requires only a wash and coating with a protective gum after imaging, the moot point being whether the gum, which is washed away on press, should be considered a chemical or not. This issue does not seem to have harmed sales. From a beginning when users were either the environmentally committed or smaller companies making their first step into ctp and who neither wanted the expense of a processor nor had the space for one, the Azura has become an almost de facto environmental plate for Agfa customers. It is being used by high volume B1 printers, the likes of Hobbs the Printers and Image Data Group signing up at Ipex, and in longer production runs. Agfa claims 100,000 impressions which gives plenty of ceiling in a market where shorter print runs are the order of the day. For longer runs it has the Amigo which gives 200,000 impressions, but which requires some processing after the imaging.

For sheetfed printers who want to achieve the continuous improvement that environmental standards demand, the move to a new plate is an obvious step. The big gains are in the elimination of spent chemistry to dispose of, saving money as well, a cleaner working environment – PPG in Portsmouth has its plate processors in the sales office – and no loss of quality.

Fujifilm Graphic System’s Graham Leeson explains that the company’s low-chem LH-PJE plate is able to hold the 10 micron spot that sharpest levels of FM screening demand. This plate demands some chemistry in processing, but only minimal amounts and when paired with a ZAC processor, with its onboard intelligent systems, can deliver a very powerful environmental solution. The technology was recognised this summer when the processor received an Intertech Award in the US as a significant development in the printing industry. The unit manages replenishment of the developer so that the concentration of the solution remains the same, at a managed temperature and delivers a consistent plate, which is crucial when running to the ISO 12647-2 standard for litho printing.

At one time Fujifilm recommended that the processor be stripped and cleaned every month. Based on feedback from the market, it has officially revised this advice to once every three months. One user stretched this to nine months, some 40,000sq m of plates, before it was cleaned, but Fujifilm is not recommending this interval. “But we have been conservative about the frequency that people needed to clean the tank, which is why we are changing the specification,” says Leeson.

Fujifilm also has in its portfolio the Pro-T, an on press processed plate, so requiring no additional chemicals in processing. It carries a premium price, reflecting the additional cost of manufacture, and it is not a plate for all printers. “For larger users, the low-chem path is best,” he says. “And in combination with the processor, nothing else can deliver as consistent a plate.”

Both Fujifilm and Agfa have introduced improved versions of the key environmental plates this year, Agfa improving the imaging speed of the Azura TS and introducing a violet sensitive version, while Fuji’s LH-PLE takes the low-chem formula into the web market. It uses a more robust aluminium alloy to withstand splitting on runs up to 300,000 and longer if baked. A negative working plate, the LH-NI3. provides the same benefits in terms of robustness and low chemistry consumption.

However, the most significant new plate has come from Kodak. This is Trillian SP, a negative working thermal imaged plate with the robustness for long runs and low chemistry usage in processing. Kodak has in Thermal Direct a working no process plate, but like Fujifilm’s Pro-T and Pro-V plates, this has a narrow market. Trillian by contrast is aimed at the world. There is no need for a pre-heat step or post imaging bake, bad news for companies supplying plate ovens, but having a major impact on energy consumption.

The plate has been in beta testing for much of this year with controlled commercial release to follow. It is a plate that can be produced at any of the company’s plants worldwide and will be the first of a new generation of plates based around the Trillian coating technology. These will be introduced in the next year or so and according to Kodak “will represent a significant shift in printers’ ability to improve performance on press and in prepress while driving out costs and reducing environmental impact”.

“It’s a new technology that is aimed at the high volume sector and is suitable also for UV or electron beam curing. Our customers are looking for significant cost savings as well as reduced environmental impact and the same kind of image quality and on press stability,” says Oscar Planas, Kodak’s vice president, marketing of prepress solutions. “Trillian is the first of several new technologies that will follow during the next year.”

It is an indication that despite the apparent maturity of the litho print market that innovation is far from finished. And it is the environment above all that is driving innovation.

Chemistry lesson

The impact of having the greenest plate can be destroyed through having on-press chemistry that does not follow the same principles.

This is why Fujifilm has begun to carry out environment audits around the press to look at ways to cut the impact of washes, founts, coatings and other chemicals that may be used. Its pressroom range is extensive and will cover almost all situations. ‘We can look at all the solutions that are used on press and help printers make the choices that reduce VOCs through cutting levels of IPA and choosing the best wash products,’ says marketing manager Graham Leeson.

‘We can make sure that there are no incompatibilities between the products and plates which would cause problems with printing conditions. We can work with the printer to achieve what they are aiming for. Normally we can reduce IPA consumption by at least 50% because it is not always possible to eliminate it completely. When it comes to coatings we can help printers switch from a UV coating to a water based coating that gives almost the same gloss levels for those that want to move away from UV.’

Agfa is also beginning to supply pressroom consumables on the same basis that to get the best from the plate, there is a need to have chemistry, plates and press working in harmony.

Explore more...