The Italian company is Europe’s first with Kodak’s Prosper 6000C and it has replaced litho printing. The printer is steadily becoming an all-digital operation.
Europe’s first Kodak Prosper 6000C is a less imposing machine that expected. It appears smaller than the photography had suggested; it seems smaller somehow than the Prosper 5000 that it follows and is certainly smaller than HP’s high speed inkjet web presses that it must compete with.
It has already won one of these battles. Leaderform, the company in Italy that has the first Kodak press in Europe, put both the Prosper 6000C and the equivalent HP press through their paces in a week-long series of trials and tests.
The Kodak machine finished in front, but perhaps there were mitigating circumstances. Leaderform has been using Kodak inkjet technology for as long as it has been available. Other Italian printers have opted for HP and Kodak was keen that the right customer would become the first user of the Prosper 6000C.
But these factors would not have counted had the press not been able to deliver on the three crucial measures of quality, cost and speed.
Managing director Luigi Berroni explains that only four years ago he considered that the Prosper was not ready. Instead the company bought a brace of Screen Truepress Jet520ZZ inkjet presses. These have performed, and continue to perform, admirably. But they fall short of the final step of delivering offset quality colour on all substrates. “At the time Screen was out in front, today this is Kodak,” he says.
The Japanese company has since launched the Truepress Jet 520HD as a machine for offset quality printing. Acknowledging the development, Berroni says that the pace of Japanese development is too slow for his liking.
There is also the issue of speed. Leaderform is looking to a time when it can replace offset printing with an all inkjet line up. To achieve this it needed the throughput that the Prosper technology alone provides.
To emphasise this, the Prosper 6000C is seated right in the middle of the main production floor. On one side is Muller Martini web offset technology; on the other side the finishing lines that convert preprinted reels into finished mailing lines, perhaps with inkjet overprinting and then the enclosing equipment and mailers that sort the pieces for distribution around Europe.
The latest inkjet development slots right into this. There is no air conditioning or environmental protection, only aluminium pipes to duct heat away from the drying systems.
The company’s remaining inkjet presses, including older Kodak Versamarks and the Screen machines, are located downstairs where they do have some protection. These have replaced litho preprint in statement printing, in direct mail where close to litho quality or productivity is needed. The step forward Leaderform looked for is delivering both quality and productivity.
Kodak believed it had taken this step previously with the Prosper 5000, but once in the real world, a host of issues became apparent. Kodak’s European sales and marketing director for inkjet systems Graham McLachlan calls them “growing pains”.
It made more sense for the company to rethink the press design, particularly the web path, rather than persist with the Prosper 5000. Machines that are in the field have been adapted and are now reliable workhorses for their users, and Kodak’s lesson has been learned.
The Prosper 5000 remains in the line up, but the newer machine is expected to gain the orders while the Prosper 1000 in standard or higher speed Plus versions will be the machine for mono work.
The change has followed the recruitment of an engineer from the former Harris web offset business who has had a huge influence on the design of the paper transport.
Both the Prosper 6000 machines, the C version which offers higher quality for litho applications and the P version for publishing applications, include 20 patents specific to the lessons learned.
The continuous inkjet technology offers inherent advantages over drop on demand in that the inks are simpler are able to print on a wider range of substrates and are also less expensive. “There can be an increase in paper cost,” says McLachlan, “but a 40% reduction in ink costs.”
This has resulted in a machine which appears to have a flat paper path and distinct break between the colours. There is an Adphos dryer after each colour head, with ducting to remove water vapour into the outside air. As the requirement is to remove 3 litres of water a minute, this must be conveyed as far from the press as possible.
It runs a 200m/min with the P version at 300m/min and potentially faster in future as the is more speed possible from the continuous inkjet system.
The Adphos near infra red technology operates on the water element of the ink and has little impact on the paper. However, waiting until all four colours have been printed would mean water penetrating the paper fibres and creating a swelling effect, leading to cockling of the finished product.
The print and dry immediately process removes this risk, enabling the Prosper to print on papers that do not have a priming or other protective layer to prevent water ingress. On the other hand it does raise the energy footprint of the press.
“The Prosper uses more energy than the HP, but the Prosper is printing more pages, and does not need a priming fluid,” says Berroni.
Leaderform prints roll to roll, the finished rolls being fed to an MBO or other finishing lines which sheet, fold, perforate and create the mailers. Other Prospers can have automated reelstands which when running to an inline finishing system will remove the problem of having to reweb the press for every new reel and the waste associated with this.
The Prosper 6000P that has been installed at Al Nasr in Dubai with Manroland Web’s Formerline folder system will have an MEG reel stand.
That machine will be printing books, though the quality has also attracted the interest from other parts of the media group. The machine in Italy is aimed firmly at replacing offset print.
“We have won contracts because of its quality,” says chief executive Federico Cozza. “This has been the right time for us to invest: customers are looking at opportunities that direct mail presents. Our sales people are convinced that the printed result is a perfect match to offset.”
Leaderform is not targeting an Italian customer base with the technology: it is looking for customers across northern Europe, including the UK.
A sample produced on gloss coated paper shows very little difference between the two processes, perhaps only a question of colour management and certainly not something that screams out that this was printed digitally.
It will be acceptable to buyers across Europe, though Cozza points out that the Italian market lags in terms of sophisticated use of data. “We have to continue to educate the Italian market,” he explains. “One problem is that we have to make sure that the marketing department is in touch and communicates with the IT department in these companies.”
Leaderform has 17 dedicated IT personnel within a workforce of 130 people. As runs become more targeted the reliance on this resource increases as each campaign has the same data preparation requirement.
The journey towards the Prosper 6000C began almost 30 years ago when Berroni wanted to install what was then a Mead inkjet system, but was prevented from doing so by exclusivity agreements. That technology was bought by Scitex and became the Versamark system before being claimed by Kodak.
Over the period Leaderform has invested in Nipson digital web printing then in a Versamark VT4000 as its first colour inkjet capacity in 2004. The Screen presses propelled the company into a higher quality transpromotional space and it then wanted to move into higher quality direct mail.
This led to a visit to Kodak’s Dayton facility to see the new Prosper 6000 technology in December last year. The deal was clinched and six months later the press was in place in the factory a few miles outside Verona.
“We had wanted to switch the VT4000 to Prosper 5000, but the technology wasn’t ready so in the interim we switched to Screen,” Berroni says.
Screen remains, meeting a need for volume at acceptable quality colour. Across the business, inkjet means that up to 50% capacity printed digitally, even before the impact of the latest investment is included.
The future clearly lies with the Kodak machine. Berroni says the initial aim is to have the press running double shifts and extra when required. Leaderform will look at the potential for a varnishing module before adding: “And then the plan in a couple of years’ time is to install another to replace the Muller Martini.”