A new channel that changed more than television: the iconic design of the Channel 4 logo
Graphic designer turned journalist and publisher Debbie Ward reflects on the late Martin Lambie-Nairn’s groundbreaking creation.
Martin Lambie-Nairn, who died on 25 December 2020, changed my life. When Channel 4 launched in November 1982 I was in my second year at art college and had just started the graphic design course. Lambie-Nairn’s Channel 4 logo is all we talked about, or more accurately argued about. Television idents were largely 2D then, and along came this 3D computer animated logo and blew our barely formed minds. Our various course tutors encouraged this discussion; it enabled them to get an awful lot of teaching into a very small timescale.
I hated it. I found it ugly and still do, though now I love it, probably because it was understanding it that changed my life.
It was actually my fine art tutor who noticed that I was wasn’t giving my opinion and hiding at the back. He held the noise back long enough to ask what I thought. “Well… it’s just… ugly,” I blurted out, to gasps of horror from my peers, “…and too fashionable.”
What followed was a masterclass of design principles, construction, space, colour, perception, mood. But the part that changed my life was the explanation that the elegance of its design and the ingenuity of its construction meant that it had the ability and flexibility to stand the test of time. “It’s one of the few logos around that will outlive all of us here,” said a man in forties to a bunch of teenagers, a man who I hope is around to know he was proved right.
I hadn’t been sure about which route to take for my specialisation, but that moment set me on the route to branding (corporate identity as it was called then). I started on that road knowing that I didn’t have to like something for it to do its job. Along the way I have learnt that persuading people away from something that they like but is doomed and towards something that is nowhere near as flash but will not date is nigh on impossible (see the London 2020 Olympics logo, height of fashion at the time of bidding but very much of its time come the actual event).
Another thing I learned when I went into publishing is that people don’t much like change. One of the first things we did after buying The Print Business magazine was to drop the ‘The’ from the title. Ten years on many still refer to us as The Print Business. Plus ça change. That apart, the first five years was spent building a really strong brand, bit by bit. In the eight years I was on Printing World, I saw three complete redesigns and every publisher ignored the fact that the readers hated them. So we have concentrated on adapting something we know our readers like and updating it by stealth. This is demonstrated on the right.
If it hadn’t been for the Channel 4 logo, I don’t think any of this would be as ingrained in me as it is. It was easier to persuade clients on to the right path in the analogue age. When I found myself sitting at a computer running Quark XPress, with a customer instructing me to move the carefully placed logo on a brochure to the left (“No too far, go back a bit, a bit more…”) where it just floated in random space, I lost the will to bring someone else’s vague ideas to life.
We run some really well put together ads in our print and online publications. And we run some that just haven’t been built to do their job. The message that works for brand marketing rarely works for direct marketing. Chopping and changing because something doesn’t give instant results will never turn anyone into a household name. To build a brand you have to be in it for the long haul. And to start as you mean to go on, not only do you need a Martin Lambie-Nairn, you have to listen to him.
Comment
Martin Lambie-Nairn is known for a large portfolio of work, the best known probably the Channel 4 ident. The original Spitting Image was one of his close collaborations and his high profile redesigns include O2 and BBC News. Good design is the product of creative people, not software, and much communication fails because it’s the wrong message in the wrong format in the wrong vehicle at the wrong time. However, no one has a crystal ball, but a good designer working in collaboration with the client has a much better chance of capturing the zeitgeist and the audience’s imagination more than marketing by committee.
A new channel that changed more than television: the iconic design of the Channel 4 logo
Graphic designer turned journalist and publisher Debbie Ward reflects on the late Martin Lambie-Nairn’s groundbreaking creation.
Martin Lambie-Nairn, who died on 25 December 2020, changed my life. When Channel 4 launched in November 1982 I was in my second year at art college and had just started the graphic design course. Lambie-Nairn’s Channel 4 logo is all we talked about, or more accurately argued about. Television idents were largely 2D then, and along came this 3D computer animated logo and blew our barely formed minds. Our various course tutors encouraged this discussion; it enabled them to get an awful lot of teaching into a very small timescale.
I hated it. I found it ugly and still do, though now I love it, probably because it was understanding it that changed my life.
It was actually my fine art tutor who noticed that I was wasn’t giving my opinion and hiding at the back. He held the noise back long enough to ask what I thought. “Well… it’s just… ugly,” I blurted out, to gasps of horror from my peers, “…and too fashionable.”
What followed was a masterclass of design principles, construction, space, colour, perception, mood. But the part that changed my life was the explanation that the elegance of its design and the ingenuity of its construction meant that it had the ability and flexibility to stand the test of time. “It’s one of the few logos around that will outlive all of us here,” said a man in forties to a bunch of teenagers, a man who I hope is around to know he was proved right.
I hadn’t been sure about which route to take for my specialisation, but that moment set me on the route to branding (corporate identity as it was called then). I started on that road knowing that I didn’t have to like something for it to do its job. Along the way I have learnt that persuading people away from something that they like but is doomed and towards something that is nowhere near as flash but will not date is nigh on impossible (see the London 2020 Olympics logo, height of fashion at the time of bidding but very much of its time come the actual event).
Another thing I learned when I went into publishing is that people don’t much like change. One of the first things we did after buying The Print Business magazine was to drop the ‘The’ from the title. Ten years on many still refer to us as The Print Business. Plus ça change. That apart, the first five years was spent building a really strong brand, bit by bit. In the eight years I was on Printing World, I saw three complete redesigns and every publisher ignored the fact that the readers hated them. So we have concentrated on adapting something we know our readers like and updating it by stealth. This is demonstrated on the right.
If it hadn’t been for the Channel 4 logo, I don’t think any of this would be as ingrained in me as it is. It was easier to persuade clients on to the right path in the analogue age. When I found myself sitting at a computer running Quark XPress, with a customer instructing me to move the carefully placed logo on a brochure to the left (“No too far, go back a bit, a bit more…”) where it just floated in random space, I lost the will to bring someone else’s vague ideas to life.
We run some really well put together ads in our print and online publications. And we run some that just haven’t been built to do their job. The message that works for brand marketing rarely works for direct marketing. Chopping and changing because something doesn’t give instant results will never turn anyone into a household name. To build a brand you have to be in it for the long haul. And to start as you mean to go on, not only do you need a Martin Lambie-Nairn, you have to listen to him.
Explore more...
Browse past issues in the Archive
What designers want from printers in 2020
Creative thinking to sell craft beer
It Has To Be Brilliant plays branding card
Push Print stretches design boundaries with neon ink from Ricoh